The purpose of this optional rule is to open the door for narrative storytelling by Players and GM's.
This game option uses critical-success/failures (rolled doubles) to determine side-effects, whether you are the Player or the GM. Some side-effects are beneficial, some are detrimental. A side-effect is similar to a critical result, but on a lesser scale.
Any time you make an ability or skill check, if you rolled even doubles (00, 22, 44, etc.) a beneficial side-effect occurs determined by the Player and agreed upon by the GM. If odd doubles are rolled (11, 33, 55, etc.) a detrimental side-effect occurs determined by the GM.
The side-effect must be related to the action for-which the action was made. For instance, if you attack a foe and roll 22, a critical-success and gain a beneficial side-effect, you can only give the side-effect relating to the foe you struck, not to someones scouting skill check. They are totally unrelated.
The side-effect determined by the Player/GM is in addition to the ruling by the GM of any critical-success of critical-failure rolled.
Example:
Bob the Bald Dwarf With Two Left Eyes attacks a ogre with his butchers knife. He rolls a 22 resulting in a critical success and declares the beneficial side-effect will be as follows, "The goram ogre is off balance from my mighty meat-cleaver blow, it can't dodge the next attack."
In the next turn Bob rolls an 11, another critical success, however it's a detrimental side-effect. The GM rules Bob caused double-damage for the crit, however he was not able to get into a defensive posture and suffers a -10 to resistance checks if he is attacked during this turn.
BareBones Fantasy RPG is not associated with Skaldcrow Games' Bare Bones Multiverse, despite similar names. Check out Glenn's products by clicking here.